Carlise tires vs. Goodyear for trailer - Event Date: 19 Feb 2025 - 01 Mar 2025

Never been a fan of goodyears and won't discuss here.  Regardless I have been extremely pleased with the Carlisle Radial Trail HD, load range "D" which is my current set of shoes.  Currently they are 4 years old, have about 20,000 miles and tread still looks nearly new.  As with any tire, they will age out before the tread does, unless you have a severe issue such as a bent axle where camber is way off.  IMHO Carlisle is an equivalent to gye with the exception that the warranty on Carlisle is 2x longer than what is offered on goodyears.

Guess what I am asking is whether the approximately (in my city) extra $60 per tire for the Goodyears is worth it in comparison to the Carlise tires.  We only use our trailer maybe one month per year, stored in cover rest of the year.  Still have three original tires plus one new tire but AAA came to our rescue when we had the flat but that tells me it's time to change.

Totally agree with gpokluda.  The most mileage i have ever put on a set of tires over 5 years is 24,000 miles and even after that, the tread looked nearly new.  I try to change sets (all 3 tires every other change) every 5 years per manufacture recommendation.